Editor's Picks of the Month
Based on claim settlement ratio, garage network, add-on flexibility and value for money on a comprehensive policy.
- Among the highest claim settlement ratios in India
- 12,200+ cashless network garages
- 8+ add-ons including unlimited zero dep
- Engine & consumables cover available
- Zero-paperwork, smartphone-based claims
- Claims processed in as little as 7 minutes
- 97.2% claim settlement ratio (H1 FY26)
- 6,000+ cashless network garages
- One of India's largest cashless garage networks
- Strong reach in semi-urban & rural India
- Backed by State Bank of India
- Comprehensive, third-party & OD options
Car Insurance Comparison Chart — All 10 Plans Side by Side
This car insurance comparison chart shows indicative comprehensive package policy premiums for a 1.2L petrol hatchback, 5 years old, IDV ~₹4,00,000–5,00,000, Mumbai, 20% NCB. SUV car insurance rates run roughly 25–40% higher than the hatchback rates below due to higher IDV and repair costs — share your exact model on WhatsApp for an accurate SUV quote. Updated June 2026.
| Plan | Annual Premium* | IDV Range | Claim Ratio | Network Garages | Plan Variants | Key Add-Ons | Review |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Car Insurance HDFC ERGO |
₹4,800 | Up to vehicle's market value | ~99.4% | 12,200+ | Comprehensive, Third-Party, Standalone OD | Zero Dep, RTI, Consumables, NCB Protect | Review |
Car Insurance Digit |
₹4,650 | Up to vehicle's market value | 97.2% | 6,000+ | Comprehensive, Third-Party | Zero Dep, Engine Protect, Roadside Assistance, NCB Protect | Review |
 Car Insurance Bajaj Allianz |
₹4,500 | Up to vehicle's market value | ~98% | 4,000+ | Comprehensive/Package, Standalone OD, Flexible (Pay As You Drive) | Zero Dep / Bumper-to-Bumper, Consumables, Roadside Assistance, Electrical Accessories | Review |
IL Private Car Package Policy ICICI Lombard |
₹4,950 | Up to vehicle's market value | ~92.9% | 6,800+ | Comprehensive, Own Damage, Third-Party, Pay As You Drive | Zero Dep, Engine Protect Plus, Key Protect, Garage Cash, RTI | Review |
 Auto Secure Tata AIG |
₹5,400 | Up to vehicle's market value | ~95.4% | 7,500+ | Comprehensive, Third-Party, Standalone OD | 20+ add-ons incl. Zero Dep, Engine Secure, Tyre Cover, RTI | Review |
SBI Private Car Package Policy SBI General |
₹5,200 | Up to vehicle's market value | 102.07% (incurred) | 20,000+ | Comprehensive, Third-Party, Standalone OD | Zero Dep, NCB Protect, Personal Accident Cover, Roadside Assistance | Review |
 Private Car Insurance New India Assurance |
₹4,700 | Up to vehicle's market value | ~96% | 3,000+ | Comprehensive, Third-Party, Standalone OD | Zero Dep, NCB Protect, Personal Accident Cover | Review |
 Private Car Insurance Reliance General |
₹4,900 | Up to vehicle's market value | ~94% | 8,500+ | Comprehensive, Third-Party, Pay As You Drive | Zero Dep, Engine Protect, Roadside Assistance, Tyre Protect | Review |
 Car Secure Future Generali |
₹4,600 | Up to vehicle's market value | 93% | 3,000+ | Comprehensive, Third-Party, Standalone OD | Zero Dep, Engine Protect, NCB Protect, Roadside Assistance | Review |
RS Car Insurance Royal Sundaram |
₹4,400 | Up to vehicle's market value | ~85% | 3,300+ | Comprehensive, Third-Party, Standalone OD | Zero Dep, Roadside Assistance, Return to Invoice | Review |
* Indicative comprehensive premiums for a 1.2L petrol hatchback, ~5 years old, IDV around ₹4,00,000–5,00,000, registered in Mumbai with 20% NCB. Actual premiums vary by car make/model, age, city, IDV, NCB and add-ons selected. Claim ratios are approximate, based on latest publicly available IRDAI/company data. Data updated June 2026.
How to Choose the Right Car Insurance Plan
1. Comprehensive vs Third-Party vs Standalone OD
Third-party cover is legally mandatory under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and its premium is fixed by IRDAI. Comprehensive cover adds protection for your own vehicle against accidents, theft, fire and natural disasters. If you already have third-party cover and just want own-damage protection, a Standalone Own Damage policy — offered by HDFC ERGO, Bajaj Allianz, ICICI Lombard, Tata AIG and others — can be a cost-effective add.
2. Check the Claim Settlement Ratio
HDFC ERGO and Digit currently report among the highest claim settlement ratios (around 99.4% and 97.2% respectively), while SBI General's incurred claim ratio of 102.07% indicates the insurer pays out more in claims than it collects in premiums for motor — generally a good sign for policyholders. A higher ratio means a smoother claims experience when you actually need it. See our full claim settlement ratio comparison for a deeper breakdown of every insurer, including the difference between claim settlement ratio and incurred claim ratio.
3. Garage Network & Cashless Repairs
SBI General (20,000+ garages), Reliance General (8,500+) and Tata AIG (7,500+) lead on network size, which matters most if you travel frequently or live outside major metros. A nearby cashless garage means you don't pay upfront and wait for reimbursement.
4. Add-Ons Worth Paying For
Zero depreciation is the most valuable add-on for cars under 5 years old — it ensures full claim payouts without depreciation deductions. Engine protect is essential in flood-prone cities like Mumbai and Chennai. Return to Invoice (RTI) is useful for newer cars in case of total loss or theft, paying the on-road price rather than the depreciated IDV. Most insurers also offer a small automatic discount for factory-fitted safety features — check for a car insurance discount for airbags and ABS at the time of quote, since some insurers apply this without it being explicitly advertised.
5. Set Your IDV Correctly
Insured Declared Value (IDV) is the maximum amount your insurer will pay in case of total loss or theft. Setting it too low reduces your premium but also your payout — always set IDV close to your car's actual current market value, especially for cars under 3 years old.
6. Terminology, Rules and Getting a Quote
In India, what's commonly called a car insurance package (insurers list their car insurance packages as "Package Policy" plans) is simply the industry term for a comprehensive policy — third-party liability and own-damage cover bundled into one. This is the minimum car insurance required in India by law for third-party liability; comprehensive is optional but strongly recommended given repair and liability costs. A generic online car insurance premium calculator can only give a rough estimate since your final price depends on your exact car model, city and claims history — for an accurate car insurance price, share your registration number and car model on WhatsApp and we'll return side-by-side quotes from all 10 insurers above within minutes. Your policy document is available for download via email and WhatsApp immediately after issuance. Commercial vehicles and trucks are priced under a separate goods-carrying-vehicle category — message us for a dedicated truck insurance quote.
Not Sure Which Car Insurance Plan Is Right for You?
Our IRDAI-licensed advisors compare all 10 plans for your car's make, model, age and city — completely free.
Talk to an Advisor — Free
